Best Seafood Dining in Delaware 2024

Delaware's oceans and bays delight diners looking for fresh seafood. While some local seafood restaurants are cherished for creative approaches to coastal cuisine, others offer a laidback and down-home feel in Delaware. Roll out the brown paper and crack open freshly steamed crabs or feast on savory plates with waterfront views. These top spots for seafood dining in Delaware will bring you to a coastal state of mind.

Continue to read to find the best seafood dining in Delaware.

Best Seafood Dining in Delaware 2024Aqua Bar & Grill 

57 Baltimore Avenue,
Rehoboth Beach, DE 19971

Located in Rehoboth Beach, Aqua Beach & Grill is a spot to enjoy a spacious outdoor deck and meals prepared by local chef, Lion Gardner. This casual and friendly dining place is recognized for a wonderful gathering at the beach and memorable moments with your loved ones. This restaurant is pet-friendly so you can bring along your four-legged furry friends for a meal with your family and friends. The menu here offers a combination of exquisite dishes for lunch, dinner, brunch, and late-night snacks. Start your meal with an appetizer of Bang Bang Shrimp, covered in bang bang sauce, cherry peppers, and scallions.

Cooter Brown's Twisted Southern Kitchen and Bourbon Bar 

70 Rehoboth Avenue
Rehoboth Beach, DE 19971

At Cooter Brown's Twisted Southern Kitchen and Bourbon Baryou can find 175 bourbons and whiskeys, whilst enjoying southern dishes like a catfish supper, sweat tea fried chicken, or shrimp and grits. When dining at this fine establishment in Rehoboth Beach, start your meal with Voodoo Shrimp, spicy shrimp, jalapeño cornbread, and amber lager beer sauce. For your entree, check out the Bourbon Glazed Salomon with Peaches, fresh salmon, maple bourbon glaze, grilled peaches, dirty rice, and veggies.

JR's Seafood Shack 

1500 Coastal Highway #1
Fenwick Island, DE 19944

With the oncoming rise of southern-style cooking, JR's Seafood Shack has a mission to bring those flavors and feelings closer to the area. This restaurant features a unique menu at the Delaware beaches that highlights the flavors and dishes of the south, affordable by keeping everything under $30. The menu boasts cuisine from land and sea from inspirations of southern recipes. Starting your meal off the right way, Summer Scallops, seared Carolina big boy scallops with grilled peach salsa and watermelon vinaigrette. For your main course, check out the Blackened Carolina Mahi Mahi, fresh Carolina mahi mahi pan blackened and served over Savannah red rice, Carolina chow, and braised green beans.

Starboard Claw 

1818 Coastal Highway
Dewey Beach, DE 19971 

This great place is known best for its steamed crabs, along with a "Claw Bar" featuring shrimp, crab legs, clams, and lobsters. You can find an array of non-seafood items at Starboard Clawand it is widely popular for famous crushes and other drinks, such as sangria, margaritas, Bloody Marys, beer, seltzers, and wine. You will find nothing short of coastal elegance and culinary excellence at the restaurant that combines contemporary design with coastal elements. Start your local meal with Calamari and Clams, sautéed Point Judith calamari and littleneck clams, roasted red pepper chimichurri, and topped with parmesan crumbs. For your main course, check out the Delmarva Steam Pot, shrimp, mussels, clams, fish, sausage, sweet corn, and baby potatoes, swimming in shellfish-tomato broth.

Atlantic Social 

19340 Lighthouse Plaza 
Rehoboth Beach, DE 19971

Between a fresh raw bar and loaded lobster rolls—New England or Chesapeake style—Atlantic Social offers an elevated take on a beloved East Coast dining tradition in a lively modern atmosphere, minutes from the Atlantic Ocean. You can find tons of fresh options, from seafood platters to salads and steaks, you can choose to share or just to start. To start your meal, we recommend the Fresh Shucked Oysters in Old Bay cocktail sauce, seasonal mignonette, and hot sauce. For your main course, keep it simple with Fish and chips, flounder, fries, and housemate herbed tartar sauce.

The Surfing Crab Restaurant & Bar 

16723 Coastal Highway
Lewes, DE 19958 

At The Surfing Crab Restaurant & Baryou will find the restaurant's passion for seafood shine through the menu. Every dish offered features the best and freshest seafood on the coast. Crabs are cooked to order at this fun-loving restaurant. To start your meal, settle for the mussels swimming in white wine sauce as a sharable. Moving onto your main course, check out the Crab and Mac and Cheese, a pasta dish of Mac with broccoli and a patty of fresh-caught crab.

Mickey's Family Crab House 

39610 Jefferson Bridge Rd,
Bethany Beach, DE 19930 

Mickey's Family Crab House is a casual, family-friendly eatery. The atmosphere of the restaurant is warm and welcoming, bringing a true taste of the Eastern Coast to the table with elaborate fresh-caught seafood. The time taken to make house dressings, sauces, crab cakes, and other menu items is set aside to bring a sense of home-cooked meals. Start your meal with the sharable Lump Crab Flatbread, topped with pesto, tomatoes, crab, corn, red pepper, onion, and mozzarella. Move onto your main entree of the Indian River, consisting of 4 oz broiled crab cake, 3 jumbo fried shrimp, fries, and corn on the cob.

Big Fish Grill Rehoboth 

20298 Coastal Highway,
Rehoboth Beach, DE 19971 

Founded in 1997, this establishment has been a part of Rehoboth Beach's community as a staple of fresh seafood. Delaware's Big Fish Grill is a premier hotspot for casual dining in the region. Using a unique blend of recipes, must-have favorites, and affordable prices, there is a dedicated following of locals. For sharable starters, check out the Broiled Baby Seafood Cakes, with crab, shrimp, and scallops over a light lobster sauce. For a main dish, divulge in the Pot 'O Mussels, fresh steamed bouchot mussels from the cold, pristine waters of Prince Edward Island, CA, served with garlic toast, and swimming in garlic wine.

One Coastal 

101 Coastal Highway,
Fenwick Island, DE 19944

Dining at One Coastal invites you to learn the story of local chef, Matt Kern, who invites guests to experience their take on fantastic food rooted in a commitment to support Delaware agriculture and watermen. You can find fine wine, cocktails, and brewed beers here, as well as some of the finest fresh-caught seafood around. For sharable starters, check out Crab and Snapdragon Apple Remoulade, topped with lemon thyme, brown butter aioli, shaved breakfast radish, and topped in brown butter crumb. Moving onto a main course, check out the Corn Fried Chesapeake Blue Catfish, Castle Valley Mills cornmeal, Sea Island red peas, Jimmy Nardello peppers, broccoli rabe, and smoked pepper butter.

Catch 54 

38931 Madison Avenue,
Selbyville, DE 19975 

With a recent acknowledgment as the best waterfront restaurant in the state of Delaware, Catch 54 is committed to serving beautiful, simple coastal cuisine in a stunning setting overlooking the bay. House specialties include signature crab cake, buttermilk fried oysters, and the famous 54 burgers, accompanied by an extensive wine list and a great selection of craft ales and cocktails. Start your dining experience with the Manhattan Clam Chowder, tomato, mirepoix, potatoes, and a side of saltine crackers. For your main meal, check out the Catch 54 Seafood Stew, fin and shellfish, tomatoes, white wine, herbs chili flake, garlic butter, lemon, and a side of toast with the added addition of linguine.

Intrigued by the chance to enjoy the finest seafood in Delaware? From casual settings on the beach to more upscale eateries, Delaware serves the finest, freshest seafood on the coast. Explore the best eating in Delaware.

Contact Your Delaware Realtor. 

Post a Comment